Subscribe to The Brief, The Texas Tribune’s everyday newsletter that updates viewers on the most important Texas information.
Max Hightower developed a passion for theatre after seeing the melodic” Hamilton.” He begged his relatives to watch it again right away when he was only 13 years old. He immediately began spending every day listening to the music.
Max, who was already singing in the chorus, remarked,” Oh my god, you can speak in a play, that’s stupid.”
Therefore, when Max, a high school senior, was cast in the Sherman High School generation of” Oklahoma,” he contributed his own solo! He put all of his effort into the production of this classic British musical about love and independence.
However, it is currently unknown if Max, a transsexual man, will be cast as the Iranian peddler Ali Hakim. Sherman school officials have essentially cast Max as the result in a very diverse play playing out in real life thanks to an uproar of immediate policy changes regarding the gender of performers and open hand-wringing about the revered American musical’s content. It’s more akin to the” Hairspray” civil rights battle than the love triangle in” Oklahoma”!
Max and several of his own scholar thespians were pulled off by the school after he was demoted from the choir to the supporting role. One by one, high school officials informed individuals that the play would be rescheduled and postponed and that they could only play roles that matched the gender that was given to them at birth.
The region changed its gender policy on Friday after the primary decision received both local and national attention. However, the area also declared that the play would now be produced by the school in an “age suitable” version.
There are only two iterations of” Oklahoma”! are offered from a company that is in possession of the registration rights: the initial and the “youth” version, which is billed as an “adaptation for pre-high school students” and has content that has been “edited to better match younger attention spans.” The character Max was previously cast to play in that version is now simply referred to as” The Peddler.” The work time of the show is one afternoon, as opposed to the two hours it was in the original.
Amy Hightower, Max’s mother, remarked that she found it offensive and that it was also aimed at Max.” I believe they chose the type that would have Max in it the least.”
The controversy surrounding transgender students ‘ involvement in a music is the most recent development in the regional discussion of transgender rights, particularly in public schools.
The conflicts, which have taken place in statehouses and school board meeting rooms all over the United States, have primarily been about exposure to athletic equipment and books in classroom libraries. However, Texas lawmakers also prohibited trans children from using hormone therapy and puberty blockers that top health organizations have approved for kids earlier this year.
A new film podcast about the residential Grapevine school district is just one example of how school districts in Texas have decided to enact stringent gender policies and evaluate the books that are available to students. The handling of” Oklahoma” by Sherman ISD worries Max’s family! has pushed that way for the region.
Phillip Hightower, Max’s father, said,” I did n’t want us to be that.” ” I wanted us to demonstrate that we could maintain a certain level of progress and consider every child’s wants.”
The school board has not voted on any rules regarding student-performers ‘ gender assigned at birth, and Sherman ISD, which has a student population of about 7,800, did not make any administrators available for comment.
Oklahoma was mentioned in one statement from the Sherman college area. ” Maturate adult themes, profane language, and sexual content” were featured. However, the production of the present has long been a mainstay in departments of large school theater. The policy regarding performers ‘ gender would n’t necessarily be applied to future performances, according to that earlier statement.
According to a city statement released on Friday, Sherman ISD values the richness of our staff and students and is aware that many of its students have found this to be particularly challenging. The situation made it clear that a more formal assessment procedure for theatrical productions and code was required. We regret that this was n’t already in place, but the District will have a stricter review and approval process going forward.
However, that has n’t done much to placate Max’s parents.
According to Phillip Hightower,” The director and the management are trying to shift the blame.” ” To shift the blame to the theatre division, the chairman, heaven, I guess perhaps the school board that approved this a month and half back,” the statement reads. Their lack of explanation disgusts me.
Centuries of creative achievement
The Sherman county’s original decision regarding sex in casting decisions, according to LGBTQ+ activists and attorneys, is the first of its kind to interfere with the arts. Theater, in particular, has a long history of reshaping female norms. Shakespeare frequently uses people to play sexual characters.
Max has not kept his identity a solution. In the seventh grade, he revealed his transgender identity to his companions, and a year later, his relatives. He receives the same treatment as another 12th graders, with the exception of some abuse and sporadic misuse of adjectives.
Max was therefore completely taken aback when he was informed they had no more star in his new position.
Max remarked,” I am aware that it is Texas and that our home is there, but no my school.” They would n’t pass something like that because they knew how bad that would get because there were so many queer students at Sherman High School, I thought.
Max was not the only trans student involved in the play whose birth sex did not match their performance. Male actors were in short supply at the school, and many students—trans and transgender alike—had missed their chance to perform the parts they desired.
Although similar cases have been reported, the now-abandoned legislation is thought to be the state’s second attempt to limit theater productions based on gender. A contract school in Fort Worth was sued by the American Civil Liberties Union for enacting a rule stating that kids could just enroll in singers based on the gender they were given at birth.
The temporary identity scheme of Sherman ISD was referred to as a “very extreme and severe example” of prejudice by Brian Klosterboer, an ACLU lawyer and seat of the State Bar of Texas ‘ LGBT Law Section. He compared it to the Fort Worth lawsuit.
However, the Sherman ISD ruling is an illustration of the extreme anti-transgender animus that exists both in Texas and across the nation, according to Klosterboer.
The rolled-back plan of Sherman ISD, according to Klosterboer and Equality Texas contacts director Johnathan Gooch, appeared to be a clear violation of Title IX, the civil rights law that forbids discrimination based on gender. The Department of Education published a notice in 2021 explaining that Title IX may be violated by discrimination based on gender personality.
myths about Texans ‘ understanding
Gooch claimed that the Sherman policy does not take into account what some Texans desire from educators. According to the Public Religion Research Institute, 75 % of Texans support LGBTQ+ non-discrimination rules.
Gooch remarked,” I believe there are some misunderstandings about what Texans typically want and expect from their school board and society rulers.”
The Hightowers found pity for LGBTQ+ problems in Sherman, a remote city of 46, 000 people located about 70 miles northeast of Dallas, to be sporadic but not impossible. Amy, who is from Howe, believed that Max might prefer the rapidly expanding city to more remote locations outside. Phillip believed that the neighborhood may develop into what they required.
The city is more accepting than it seems, according to Valerie Fox, the founder of the neighborhood LGBTQ+ volunteer Grayson Pride, but allyship is kept secret out of concern for public backlash.
Fox said,” If we need to, we can get some money if we get a lot of secret support.” They’ll give it to us, but they do n’t want to appear on the banner of a sponsor. They do not want anyone to be aware.
Because one of Fox’s children is gay and she did n’t think Sherman supported LGBTQ+ identities, Fox founded Grayson Pride. Admission has quadrupled since she founded the volunteer four years ago, according to her.
The Hightowers have thought about leaving the condition to live with Max’s relatives and where there is less worry about how Max will be treated, but it is not an easy decision.
Phillip remarked,” I do n’t really want to leave this place.” ” This is where I want to alter.”
Out of worry and fear, Max’s parents had kept his change a secret from some family members, but after the district removed their child from the crucial role, they went to Facebook and made the experience public. They claimed that the response has been largely and quickly positive.
We may have gotten in touch but long ago if I had known we had all the resources and support, Amy said.
Grayson Pride and a number of neighborhood people intend to attend Sherman ISD’s Monday school committee meeting. The meeting’s established plan does not include the postponement of the play.
Max claimed that the environment at school has entirely changed since regional broadcaster KXII announced the play’s postponement. He is followed around by individuals, who have disparaged him negatively. His parents excused him from class and decided to spend the rest of the year at a resort.
Max remarked,” Citizens were attempting to follow me to the restroom to see which one I would enter.”
According to Gooch, procedures like the one in Sherman ISD create a hostile environment that encourages more discrimination in addition to violating Title IX. According to a statement from the Trevor Project, 86 % of LGBTQ youth believe that current political discourse has negatively impacted their well-being.
Disclosure: The Texas Tribune is a nonprofit, nonpartisan media firm that receives funding in part from donations from people, foundations, and commercial sponsors. Justice Texas, Facebook and State Bar of Texas have been fiscal followers of The Tribune. Financial backers have no influence on the Tribune’s media. Here is a record of them all.
