The most recent Vatican document, which rejects the fundamental idea of altering one’s genetic sex, has received mixed reviews from transgender people in the Christian community.
On Monday, the Vatican released a statement calling gender-affirming operation and infertility as grave human rights violations.
Named “Dignitas Infinita” (Infinite Dignity), the 20-page document has been in development for five years under the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith. Pope Francis approved the release date of March 25 and mandated its publication.
The report provides a list that includes contraception, death, surrogate motherhood, and conflict as violations of human respect.
The Vatican reaffirmed its opposition to “gender idea,” which is the idea of changing one’s biological sex. It urged against the haughtiness of trying to “make oneself God” and affirmed that God had created man and woman as different biological people.
Trans Rights Under Attack
Jawanza James Williams, a campaigner and organizer for the Brooklyn group, claimed that this theory had led to an assault on transgender persons’ rights.
Williams took to X to read,” Our Trans relatives are under IMMENSE attack, regularly. Like on your trans &, female nonconforming/fluid friends/loved kinds”.
“Trans individuals are sacred, and the Vatican’s location makes no difference on this *eternal* reality”, they added.
One Catholic trans professor from Leicester criticized the theory, taking to X to read about a trans man who was severely beaten and had broken bones in her face following a violent assault in Coventry, UK.
This kind of response is further bolstered by the Vatican statement released today, which suggests that people like this trans person underneath are disrespecting their dignity. Unsatisfactory and irresponsible”, religious trainer George White wrote.
The Vatican on Gender Theory
The Vatican addressed female idea, stating that the Church recalls “human living in all its aspects, both physical and spiritual, is a gift from God”.
This product must be sincerely given and put to good use. According to sex principle, having a personal sense of self-determination amounts to a concession to the age-old temptation to create oneself God.
According to The Vatican, sex concept “intends to claim the greatest possible change that exists between living people: physical difference”.
While recognizing the potential for “genital anomalies,” it made a point that these medical procedures do not conform to the definition of sexual alter as defined in the document.
Nicolete Burbach, the prospect expert on social and environmental fairness at the London Jesuit Centre, claimed Nicolete Burbach’s statement showed how reluctant people are to discuss the body in a queer perspective.
Burbach criticized the Vatican’s termination of transgender rights, citing its disturbed history on individual dignity.
She believed that the main difficulty with the document is infirming the Church’s devotion to human dignity despite its “troubling story.”
The Vatican’s charter reaffirmed its antagonism to contraception, death, and the death sentence. Additionally, it acknowledged that sexual abuse is a widespread threat to human respect and is prevalent both within the Catholic Church and community as a whole.
LGBTQ+ Groups Outraged by Catholic Document
Ymania Brown, head of Equality Australia’s TransEquality, criticized the declaration, claiming that it “takes us back to the dark years.”
She said,” These offensive and insulting statements disregard the diversity of the people and the growing body of scientific proof regarding sex and gender.”
Ms. Brown urged religious organizations to listen to LGBTIQ+ people in their own spiritual communities.
“As a transgender girl and devoted Catholic, I see myself as God’s creation and a person deserving of love, admiration, and assistance.”
Tony Briffa, a former mayor of Hobsons Bay and an advocate for transgender, claimed that the declaration rejects transgender experiences and voices.
I was a Catholic woman who was subjected to unconstitutional and superfluous medical treatment as a child because of my trans variation, and she expressed her disappointment at the Vatican’s hypocrisy and lack of understanding.
The Vatican ignores the fact that natural sex, along with sex traits and gender identity, exist in a spectrum, making it obsolete and harmful. I urge the Vatican to arrange a meeting with transgender and intersex individuals so they can become wise,” she continued.
