When to shift or how to be? Tennessee families are forced to make difficult decisions by trans laws

Misty and her 15-year-old daughter stayed in a resort close to the Cincinnati hospital on their first trip to Ohio to see if they needed medical attention.

Two months later, on their next trip, they departed from their Knoxville home at 4:30 a.m. and traveled for more than four hours while admiring the sunrise from the interstate. At 10:00 am on the next visit, an endocrinologist was waiting for them.

They waited in a Cincinnati CVS parking lot for two hours before leaving for home that evening after Misty’s father, Chris, had prepared breakfast for their two younger children because Tennessee pharmacies would never fill an estrogen prescription for her daughter. Misty traveled two hours by car on a Wednesday evening in December to Waynesville, North Carolina, and then back to pick up another prescription.

In front of Tennessee legislators and Gov. The drive to their Knoxville physician had taken 15 minutes when Bill Lee approved new legislation in March that forbade gender-affirming care for transgender children. One mile separates them from their usual store.

Misty explained why she is willing to take the frequent road trips, saying, “It’s definitely saving her life.” That is the crux of the matter. It is a life-saving procedure.

Parents across the state are making hard choices for their families regarding where to stay and how to find health care as a result of Tennessee’s new ban on gender-affirming care for minors. Some people are debating where and when to move as well as whether to completely leave the state. Others use it as a means of navigating out-of-state healthcare and providing the best treatment for their child when moving is not an option.

How many transgender and intersex individuals reside in the US? (READ MORE) New LGBTQ+ rules will have an enormous impact.

There are many people who might want to leave but are unable to do so for a variety of reasons. According to Campaign for Southern Equality, an Asheville, North Carolina-based nonprofit that supports LGBTQ people, Emma Chinn, a program administrator in Nashville, “financial considerations are important.” Finding a new career, as well as the expense of leaving your home and other support networks, are all major issues. Simply put, not everyone can accomplish that.

Drugs, hormone therapies, and uncommon surgical procedures for transgender children are prohibited by the new Tennessee rules. By April, Tennessee residents who are already receiving that treatment may stop receiving it. People like Misty and Chris’s have been forced to find gender-affirming care in different states as a result of some Tennessee physicians who have already stopped providing these treatments.

Tennessee is surrounded by states with new restrictions on gender-affirming care, with the exception of Virginia, though some states’ regulations have been upheld in court. According to the Campaign for Southern Equality, some Tennessee communities travel up to eight hours to visit doctors in South Carolina and Illinois after leaving Ohio. Tennessee people may have started seeing doctors before August in North Carolina, and South Carolina lawmakers are anticipated to acquire a restriction once more in 2024.

In states where care has been outlawed or impacted, the Southern Trans Youth Emergency Project, a regional initiative of Campaign for Southern Equality, has collaborated with two Tennessee nonprofits and offered financial grants, individual referrals, and group training. Families have used the $500 grants for out-of-state travel for gender-affirming clothing, telehealth appointments, moving expenses, and care. The business had given 55 offers to Tennessee people as of December.

Keeping their baby healthy and alive is a major concern for many families. In a 2022 research published in the Canadian Medical Association Journal, the risk of death effort was almost eight times higher for transgender children than it was for cisgender classmates.

According to Chinn, “People are actually moving hills to do whatever they can to provide for their children and simply stay afloat.”

A punch to the gut

The fact that Chris, a software engineer, and Misty work from home and have more flexible schedules has allowed their family to travel outside of the state. As insurance has become more complex, they have been able to access two offers from Campaign for Southern Equality that have assisted with medical costs. To protect their child’s protection, they are going by their first names.

The couple considered relocating to the Northeast, where trans rights are better protected, but they ultimately chose to remain in Tennessee. The weather and the lake they recently built are just a few of the smaller, even “crazy” grounds, but there are also more important factors to take into account. They call Tennessee home. Both Chris and Misty’s people reside in the Knoxville neighborhood. Living costs had skyrocket if you relocate to the Northeast. Although their two oldest kids no longer reside at home, uprooting the younger relatives may cause them disruption.

“Everyone of our families is here,” Chris remarked. “Tennessee gives us a great lifestyle.”

Additionally, Cincinnati visits are only short-lived. In less than three decades, their child may turn 18. They would be more likely to leave if she were younger, they were unable to work from home, or she wasn’t emotionally stable, according to Misty.

Related discussions are occurring in residences all over the state.

Jason and his wife are evaluating their site as they take into account their 10-year-old’s impending youth. Jason has spent the majority of his 20-year law enforcement career in Middle Tennessee. In a few years, she might want to start receiving gender-affirming treatment, but she hasn’t yet. Jason may be eligible for retirement gains in nine years, but he’s not sure if that will happen because of the new state law.

Jason, who also requested to go by his first name, said, “We have to help our child.” “We are going to have to go somewhere else if we are not allowed to do that in the state of Tennessee through gender-affirming wellness attention.” It’s disgusting.

They are thinking about the Washington, D.C., region. The income earnings they had anticipated may decrease as a result of their move, but his child may still be able to receive any necessary care.

When Jason’s baby was 6 years old, she confided in her mother that she was feeling more like a girl and needed her assistance. Her parents have encouraged her to travel. All we needed to hear, according to Jason, was statistics on death rates and the lower risk associated with understanding and support.

Jason and his wife frequently check in on their child to see how she is adjusting to the transgender student bathroom law that will be in effect in 2021. She has support from her teachers and administrators, but that hasn’t always been the case.

Jason remarked, “All she has to do is inform us, ‘It’s just too much,’ and we’ll go.”

Politicians in Tennessee who supported the gender-affirming treatment ban claimed that their goal was to protect children. Portland, Tennessee-based Republican Representative William Lamberth advised counseling rather than “cutting off brain parts” and irreversible treatment. Requests for comment on this story went unanswered by him.

Lamberth remarked to other politicians in February, “What these kids need is love and support, mental health treatment, and time.” “They need time to process their feelings regarding that transform.”

Jason spoke with more than a few Democratic lawmakers about the matter during his time at the state’s Capitol. Age restrictions on procedure are not opposed by him, but he opposes the use of hormone therapy and restrictions on puberty blockers, which delay the development of the disease and give patients more time to make more informed decisions. Some legislators have secretly supported him but finally chose to support their group, he claimed.

Jason remarked, “It’s a blow to the gut.” Many of these rules do appear to be severe and contradict what experts are saying. They don’t give a damn.

Chris, who identified as financially conservative, supported both Democratic governors. In their first term, Bill Lee and former President Donald Trump. He and Misty have been frustrated and incensed by the governor’s and lawmakers’ approval of laws that affect transgender children.

Chris said, “We’re simply trying to keep our child alive until she’s old enough to make her own choices.” Many of the individuals who support these types of laws don’t even fully comprehend what the law is accomplishing.

Driving Licenses, School, and Navigating Health Care

The discussion of trans care started for Misty and Chris about five years ago. Their baby was more feminine when she was younger, and she came out as gay in second grade. She had mental health issues, which led to numerous in-patient stays, addictions, and suicide attempts. She revealed to her mother that she was a woman in sixth grade. They ultimately decided to start taking estrogen and puberty blockers after numerous consultations with health professionals and therapists. They are not thinking about having her have surgery, but at age 18, she is capable of doing so.

Chris remarked, “Truly, not much has changed.” “It’s the exact same person.” The person has always been the same.

Both Chris and Misty were raised in traditional, Christian homes. The majority of their lifelong friends come from similar families. Chris found it difficult to reconcile his faith with sexuality and gender distress.

“As fundamentalist parents, we believe it is our responsibility to impart the Bible to our children,” Chris said. “As a result, it leaves you unsure of what to do. It was challenging.”

Chris claimed that rejecting their child or withholding aid was never an option and that he was trying to learn more about gender distress. Both parents emphasized the care and consideration that went into each clinical decision and the fact that neither of them—not even their daughter—have taken this matter lightly.

Homeschooling for Misty and Chris’s daughter was chosen as a result of Tennessee law governing school restrooms. Using a unique restroom entails paying closer attention to her change. Additionally, it might entail using the restroom on the opposite side of the building. She later dropped out and started studying at home. Her mental health issues have lessened since their child graduated from high school and as her gender-affirming treatment has advanced, according to Misty.

Living in Tennessee as the political winds have targeted trans people has been challenging for them, aside from the new travel transportation for gender-affirming attention and bathroom issues. The state also passed a law on gender identification for driver licenses in 2023, which, according to Misty, complicated their daughter’s learning curve for driving and raised potential safety concerns for her. Families and friends’ relationships have been impacted, and perhaps teachers and classmates have made derogatory remarks. Their daughter enjoys volleyball, but there isn’t a place for her to play. Misty calls ahead to make sure businesses and other organizations are accepting.

“How much am I going to be able to do that? I keep her in a small bubble, but I’m wondering,” Misty remarked.

Relocating to Virginia from Tennessee

People in Tennessee who have relocated experience additional difficulties. In July, Kristen Chapman moved her two daughters from Nashville to Richmond, Virginia, so that her youngest may continue receiving gender-affirming care. Their dad has stayed in Nashville to work. Although she felt the move was important, it turned out to be much harder than she had anticipated.

Smith remarked, “It’s been a tough landing.” “The children are still very upset from having their family split up, leaving all of their friends and everything they’ve ever known, and trying to start over.”

When they found a house, Chapman had hoped that “everything might fall into place,” she said. But it has been more expensive than she had anticipated to move, find a job that suits her, and switch schools for both 17- and 15-year-old youth.

Due to new direction in Virginia, Willow’s teachers at her new school frequently referred to her by her previous name. This was one of the reasons she chose to attend childcare until it was more convenient for her. As legislators discussed their options over the past year, they were also dealing with the mental trauma they had. Chapman had long given her children’s schooling top priority, planning for prestigious magnet schools in Nashville, but then her main concern is their mental health.

According to Chapman, all households in Tennessee who have a transgender child are dealing with mental health issues that are of an entirely different nature due to being singled out and deemed unworthy. “The effects of the past year have a longer reach than I did not anticipate.”

Regular six- to eight-hour drives to Willow’s medical facility didn’t seem manageable. Even so, she didn’t feel like her family was welcome or safe in Tennessee, where she was born and raised for about 35 years, outside of the logistics.

She remarked, “It was no longer home.” “I believed that if my kids were in a place where they were wanted, they would have more opportunity to become the people they want to be in the long run.”


Visit TennesseeLookout.com to read more.